• Latest
  • Trending
BMW 20 d

Vehicle warranties and Consumer Law in India

10 years ago
ADVERTISEMENT
Citroen CNG Ready C3

Citroen C3 CNG now available for sale across India

15 hours ago
2025 Maruti Fronx Colors all new model colors photos 2025 Fronx

2025 Maruti Fronx Colors: Blue, Brown, Red, White, Silver, Grey

17 hours ago
Royal Enfield Siddhartha Lal 2025

Royal Enfield Fuels Eicher Motors’ Historic FY25 Performance with 1 Million Motorcycle Sales

22 hours ago
MG Windsor PRO EV

MG Windsor PRO records 8,000 Bookings within 24 Hours of Launch

2 days ago
Mercedes-Benz India sold 11,469 new cars in Jan-Sep 2022

Mercedes-Benz India announces 2-Stage Price Revision Due to Forex Fluctuations

2 days ago
GaadiKey
  • Bikes
    • Hero
    • Honda
    • TVS
    • Bajaj
    • Suzuki
    • Royal Enfield
    • Yamaha
    • Ather
    • KTM
    • Aprilia
    • Vespa
    • Harley Davidson
    • BMW
    • Kawasaki
    • Ducati
    • Yezdi
    • Ampere
  • Cars
    • Maruti Suzuki
    • Tata
    • Hyundai
    • Mahindra
    • Toyota
    • Kia
    • Honda
    • MG
    • Renault
    • Volkswagen
    • Nissan
    • Skoda
    • Citroen
    • Jeep
    • Audi
    • BMW
    • Mercedes-Benz
    • Lexus
    • Volvo
    • Isuzu
    • BYD
  • Bike Reviews
  • Car Reviews
  • Photos
  • Contact
  • Best Bikes 2025
    • Best Motorcycles 2025
    • 2025 Hero Splendor+ XTEC 2.0
    • 2025 Royal Enfield Classic 350
    • 2025 Hunter 350
    • 2025 Royal Enfield Scram 440
    • 2025 Royal Enfield Classic 650
    • Best Scooters 2025
    • 2025 Honda Activa 6G
    • 2025 TVS Jupiter
    • 2025 Suzuki Access
    • Best Electric Scooters 2025
    • 2025 Honda Activa e:
    • 2025 Honda QC1
  • Best Cars 2025
    • 2025 Tata Curvv EV
No Result
View All Result
GaadiKey
No Result
View All Result
Home Advice

Vehicle warranties and Consumer Law in India

Anand Chaudhuri by Anand Chaudhuri
July 12, 2015 - Updated on January 12, 2020
in Advice, Featured, Guest Articles, Manufacturer Liability
1
BMW 20 d
3.6k
VIEWS
Share on WhatsappShare on FacebookShare on Twitter

[anandTop]

BMW 20 d

Every new and used car purchased through the relevant vehicle sales agreement contains warranties
about the mechanical soundness, road worthiness and performance capabilities of the vehicle
amongst others. These agreements also list the circumstances in which such warranties could be
limited or denied to the owner, for example for damage to the vehicle which results from negligent
use, improper operation and improper or unauthorised repair, lack of or improper maintenance,
environmental influences, flood, accident etc.

Owners are also provided with detailed user manuals on proper car use and maintenance, failure to
adhere to which also, such manufacturers deny or limit their liability for an alleged breach of
vehicle warranty. However where negligence or misuse of the vehicle is denied and the
manufacturer’s assurances and warranties fail the owner post-sale, what are the options left to the
suffering car buying consumer.

The Consumer Protection Act, 1986

In addition to other possible civil law remedies, the Consumer Protection Act, 1986 (the Act) through
the appropriate Consumer Dispute Redressal Agency (District Forum, State Commission or
National Commission depending on appropriate jurisdiction set by location of cause of action, claim
amount etc.) may provide some ready and efficient solutions to the consumer for such paid-for
defective goods and/or deficient services and possibly restrictive and unfair trade practices for any
false or misleading statements, warranties and assurances.

The Act defines key words like “defect”, “deficiency”, “service” and “unfair trade practices”. These
cover matters like any fault, imperfection or shortcoming in the quality, quantity, potency, purity,
nature or standard of goods and manner or time for performance of services (required by law or
implied/express terms of a contract or as represented). Further, “unfair trade practice” has been
defined to include misleading and false statements, representations and warranties and other unfair
methods or deceptive practices on the public and consumer for the purpose of promoting the sale,
use or supply of any goods or for the provision of any service.

Waterlogged-Cars

Complaint and Procedure

The consumer who has acquired or is authorised to make use of such paid-for goods and services for
non-commercial and private use purposes, may through a complaint in writing along with
supporting documents and affidavits (if required) evidencing defective goods and/or deficient
services and/or unfair trade practices can file after payment of prescribed court fees, the written
complaint against the seller, trader, manufacturer or service provider (as the case maybe) with the
appropriate Consumer Dispute Redressal Agency for relief.

Sec.24A of the Act prescribes a limitation period of 2 years from the date of cause of action (reason
for the complaint) which could be extended for “sufficient cause” shown in an appropriate case.
Subject to a hearing and adjudication on the complaint so filed and subsequent to a reply or written
statement (if any) against the complaint by the opposite party, if the complainant’s case is made out,
the nature and quantum of relief found legally justified could take the form of monetary
compensation for loss, injury or damage suffered, repair or replacement of goods, removal of
defects, repayment of price paid, withdrawal or non-manufacture of hazardous goods etc.

Rain Check

Recent Case Law on alleged mechanical defect caused by water damage “hydrostatic lock” in
a premium car, onus on complainant to substantiate mechanical damage and unreasonable
repair costs within warranty period not justified

Delhi State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission decision
Alok Gupta vs Bmw India Pvt. Ltd. on 14 March, 2013

(Please click to view complete judgement.)

Important features:

  • The defect of hydrostatic lock occurs when driving is undertaken in waterlogged area and
    conditions where the water is above the level of the air intake system or the cars speed is
    excessive, creating a tall bow wave. While driving in waterlogged area, the speed of the car
    has got to be slowed and it has to be driven slowly and cautiously.
  • Vehicle had been driven against the instructions contained in the Manual Book and also the
    instructions and advice given to the buyer at the time of purchase, resulting in hydrostatic
    lock damage.
  • Damage caused to the engine was a user related damage, it is not covered under the
    warranty. It was not the case of manufacturing defect and therefore it was not covered under
    the terms of warranty. Under the circumstances, there was no question of any replacement of
    the car.
  • Mere fact that vehicle was taken to service station for one or two times does not ipso facto
    prove manufacturing defect. Onus was on the complainant to prove his case of alleged
    mechanical defect by an expert opinion or some kind of reliable evidence, mere allegation is
    not enough.
  • It is also undisputed that the car was within the warranty period. It was a costly luxury car
    and under the circumstances, if the car was towed to the workshop of the dealer, it was his
    duty to attend the problem free of cost and to make it road-worthy. The demand of a sum of
    Rs. 2-3 Lacs for its dismantling and repair was unjustified and amounted to deficiency of
    service and also amounted to adopting unfair trade practice.
  •  The Evidence Act or Civil Procedure Code are not applicable to proceedings before
    Consumer Courts. Disputes are to be decided on the yardstick of reasonableness and
    probability. Principles of Natural Justice do apply in full force.

 

[anandBottom]

Anand Chaudhuri

Anand Chaudhuri

Anand is a practicing Advocate who also writes and publishes articles on Indian and Commonwealth case laws through Medium

Comments 1

  1. Rahul Gupta says:
    3 years ago

    Hare Krishna
    Anand Sir,
    I have booked the car on 18/04/2022 for Rs.9,75,000 but at the time of delivery (21/05/2022) the car price has increased to Rs.10,00,000/-.
    Please let me know can i take the refund of excess amt. i.e. Rs.25,000/- from the Car dealer.
    You can call me @ 816 919 2320.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent News

Citroen CNG Ready C3

Citroen C3 CNG now available for sale across India

May 15, 2025
2025 Maruti Fronx Colors all new model colors photos 2025 Fronx

2025 Maruti Fronx Colors: Blue, Brown, Red, White, Silver, Grey

May 15, 2025
Royal Enfield Siddhartha Lal 2025

Royal Enfield Fuels Eicher Motors’ Historic FY25 Performance with 1 Million Motorcycle Sales

May 15, 2025
MG Windsor PRO EV

MG Windsor PRO records 8,000 Bookings within 24 Hours of Launch

May 14, 2025
Mercedes-Benz India sold 11,469 new cars in Jan-Sep 2022

Mercedes-Benz India announces 2-Stage Price Revision Due to Forex Fluctuations

May 14, 2025
Mr. Ajinkya Firodia, Vice Chairman & Managing Director, Kinetic Engineering Ltd

Kinetic Watts and Volts Ltd. to Carry the Kinetic Legacy into the Electric Future

May 14, 2025

Search this Website

No Result
View All Result

About

GaadiKey

GaadiKey blog is a one stop portal for all the latest in the automobile industry. We are a bunch of people who are passionate about bikes and cars. We share the experience, reviews and stuff connected to Gaadis.

Contact

  • Contact us

Best Cars in 2025

  • 2025 Toyota Hyryder
  • 2025 Grand Vitara
  • 2025 Maruti Fronx
  • 2025 Maruti WagonR
  • 2025 Tata Punch
  • 2025 Mahindra XUV 3XO
  • 2025 Hyundai Creta
  • 2025 Toyota Taisor
  • 2025 Tata Curvv EV

Best Bikes in 2025

  • 2025 Royal Enfield Classic 350
  • 2025 Hunter 350
  • 2025 Royal Enfield Scram 440
  • 2025 Royal Enfield Classic 650
  • 2025 Hero Splendor+ XTEC 2.0
  • 2025 Honda Activa 6G
  • 2025 TVS Jupiter
  • 2025 Suzuki Access
  • 2025 Honda Activa e:
  • 2025 Honda QC1

© 2025 GaadiKey - Prime GaadiKey.

No Result
View All Result
  • Bikes
    • Hero
    • Honda
    • TVS
    • Bajaj
    • Suzuki
    • Royal Enfield
    • Yamaha
    • Ather
    • KTM
    • Aprilia
    • Vespa
    • Harley Davidson
    • BMW
    • Kawasaki
    • Ducati
    • Yezdi
    • Ampere
  • Cars
    • Maruti Suzuki
    • Tata
    • Hyundai
    • Mahindra
    • Toyota
    • Kia
    • Honda
    • MG
    • Renault
    • Volkswagen
    • Nissan
    • Skoda
    • Citroen
    • Jeep
    • Audi
    • BMW
    • Mercedes-Benz
    • Lexus
    • Volvo
    • Isuzu
    • BYD
  • Bike Reviews
  • Car Reviews
  • Photos
  • Contact
  • Best Bikes 2025
    • Best Motorcycles 2025
    • 2025 Hero Splendor+ XTEC 2.0
    • 2025 Royal Enfield Classic 350
    • 2025 Hunter 350
    • 2025 Royal Enfield Scram 440
    • 2025 Royal Enfield Classic 650
    • Best Scooters 2025
    • 2025 Honda Activa 6G
    • 2025 TVS Jupiter
    • 2025 Suzuki Access
    • Best Electric Scooters 2025
    • 2025 Honda Activa e:
    • 2025 Honda QC1
  • Best Cars 2025
    • 2025 Tata Curvv EV

© 2025 GaadiKey - Prime GaadiKey.